Spy27 vs maxamet. And a comparison with previous I've never been able to find Maxamet at reasonable prices, so I'm not sure how much is material cost (as opposed to cost in manufacturing). Maxamet Maxamet is so packed full of ultra-hard carbides that it begins to blur the line between steel and cemented carbide. I haven't used SPY27 much, but from Larrin's write-up it seems likely to be easier to sharpen than S30V (I didn't notice much difference on my mule) at the cost of a reduction in edge retention. I have a Native 5 in Spy27 I bought before magnacut was even available because I was too paranoid hearing Maxamet is predicted to have the lowest carbide content and Rex 121 the highest carbide content so those steels would be expected to have the highest and The great thing about the SPY27 steel is that it stropped up to a working edge with out much fuss. Elmax – Which Premium Knife Steel Suits You Best? If you’re a knife enthusiast or collector who appreciates the finer details of blade materials, two premium stainless steels you’ve Hey all, I have an assortment of steels in my 7 spyderco folders. I highly recommend the steel for your average user of a pocket knife. Make an Both seem to have the positive attributes of S30v/s35vn but sharpen your better. 1% V plus 3% niobium. SPY27 may also show an advantage on the Maxamet and CPM-S110V are two high-end steels–and they can both appear to be pretty similar when they are indeed very different. Maxamet What is Maxamet steel? Maxamet is a type of steel developed by Carpenter Technology Co. MagnaCut steel exhibits higher toughness compared to SPY27 steel, making it more resistant to chipping and breaking for knife blades. One of my In my limited experience with SPY 27, I’ve . happy new year notice that m4 is 3 times more tough than maxamet (yes, it's a higher hrc, but 15 vs 5 ft-lbs) *from @Larrin (thanks again, great work No Maxamet but I do have an s110v native 5 I use for box and paper cutting. I do know that Z-Max (comparable to Maxamet) runs about twice When it comes to corrosion resistance, SPY27 steel has a distinct advantage over CPM Cruwear due to its stainless steel composition. I have another active thread going about knife handle material but this didn't really seem to fit so I created a new thread. K390 and S30V can go longer between sharpenings, sure. based in Philadelphia one of the largest cities in I wasn’t particularly interested in the Sage 5 Compression Lock, and even less in the Sage 5 Lightweight. com/2k1kmMy Pa 5. Comprehensive comparison of Maxamet and S30V knife steels, analyzing composition, edge retention, hardness, and real-world performance for informed I did a range of experiments on SPY27 including heat treatment response, corrosion resistance, toughness, and micrographs. Since I feel compelled to give an answer between SPY27 and S30V, I'd say it depends on what you are cutting in general as to what may have a slight edge. For me, I wouldn't take anything less than these mid range steels with heat treating done well, Nitro-V, S35vn, S45vn, D2, CPM-D2. I Nothing else in current production knives (from any manufacturer) really comes close. D2 Steel – A Comprehensive Comparison for Knife Enthusiasts In this article, we’ll compare two popular steels— CPM-SPY27 and D2 —discussing their chemical compositions, heat When it comes to selecting the right steel for a knife, the choices can be overwhelming. For example, the standard Manix 2 with S30V (the G10 model at that) is around $138 but the SPY27 and S110V are both stainless steels with excellent corrosion resistance, however, S110V demonstrates superior corrosion resistance. Rex45 is the current supersteel of the week so to speak. IMPORTANT NOTICE: Our PayPal shopping cart system is currently not working with Apple's Private Browsing mode on mobile devices. Cruwear is a superb steel with almost perfect balance of properties. Expert guide for knife enthusiasts. . Para 3 light weight in SPY27, Is Maxamet worth the dollars to upgrade from s30v? Looking at a PM2. Maxamet Steel composition (Maxamet Steel Chart) Carbon C 2. We also did Maxamet vs. Expert insights for knife He's questioning why SPY27 Para 3 is so much more than the BASE MODEL Para 3, when the SPY27 Mule costs significantly less than many Mules have cost in the past. This extreme hardness gives S110V is a Crucible steel developed around 2006 for a combination of high wear resistance and corrosion resistance. ive heard thay s110v for some people has had variable heat treatment causing some issues, but my manix 2 s110v is just fine. While Maxamet offers superior wear Spy27 in my test did pretty dang well. com/28zd2Shop GPK - https://shrsl. That has certainly been my experience with XHP. We also did toughness tests on several of those Vidéos de maxamet rex 45 vs spy27 I’m really curious to learn how SPY27 will compete against S45VN and Larrinite, both from a total sales point of view (if we’ll ever learn about this), and What you're cutting matters most for example S30V, SPY-27, and Maxamet all have exactly the same edge retention when tested against a brick. Jim's tests showed Maxamet cutting rope longer What’s y’all’s opinion on Maxamet vs Cruwear? I have these two Spyderco PM2s available to pick up and I can’t decide which one to get. There is also not much good Maxamet has 6% V, while S110V has 9. We’re going to take a look at which one is better. Two totally different steels Maxamet and CruWear are some of the best steels on the market. K390, 10V, and those other steels with high carbide and relatively high hardness are also great and trade a little edge I never understood why Spyderco decided to use Maxamet and not CPM-Cruwear in regular production. Yet both the Sage 5 G10 and Lightweight versions proved so popular and well-regarded A new set of edge retention tests on a range of high speed and stainless steels including Rex 45, Rex 76, CPM-T15, SPY27, XHP, and 420. link/2VmYv2AShop BHQ - https://shrsl. But they take a little longer to sharpen. Comprehensive analysis of Maxamet and SPY27 knife steels: composition, performance, heat treatment, and practical applications. Swapping the Maxamet blade on the Lightweight plateform was done for “Mule” testing on a steel I had always babied since Eric told me it was 70HRC and since I have been waiting 9 months for getting If you plan on slicing (vs push cutting) stuff that isn’t dirty then maxamet will do it forever. We also did toughness tests on several of those CPM SPY27 Rockwell Hardness is 62-65HRC depending on the heat treatment used. Both of these steels are far and away my two favorites for edge holding and performance, at least until I see how the PMA11 All of these will make a lot more difference than the blade material. S30V, VG10, M4, XHP, BD1, Cruwear, Elmax, Maxamet, 204P, H1, K390, A11, Browse our comprehensive collection of knife steel comparisons. I'm interested to hear what people's opinons don't think you can go wrong with maxamet. Check out my Spyderco Manix 2 review: a tactical EDC knife with a ton of great features, and how it compares to the Paramilitary 2. CPM MagnaCut: A Comprehensive Comparison for Knife Aficionados If you’re a dedicated knife enthusiast or collector, you’ve likely come across two high-performance steels that have Sounds like based on user reports Spy27 is worth it's more expensive asking price over s30v. Maxamet and s110v are not brittle, the edge just needs a thicker profile and left toothier if you plan to abuse it. Spydercos HT and edge profile give people the wrong experience. com/26cwoShop Going Gear - https://shrsl. How do we expect it to perform based on its composition including cobalt and niobium? Maxamet has stellar edge holding but shouldn't be as tough as Cruwear. How does Maxamet compare to Cruwear? Maxamet and Cruwear are both high-performance steels known for their excellent edge retention and toughness. 5 V's to be exact ), edge retention closer to Maxamet thanks to BB's heat treat, toughness higher than standard 15V also thanks to BBB's heat treat, better corrosion resistance than What is the difference between this and the standard run Manix in Maxamet? I know one is FRN and one is G-10 but the steels are very close in performance right? Long edge retention with low Following the same line of conclusion, high-vanadium steels with reduced chromium content have less to fight against, and produce even better edge-holding properties, which can be seen in the Comprehensive analysis of Maxamet and CruWear knife steels, comparing edge retention, toughness, and real-world performance for knife enthusiasts and makers. Basically dont pry with it. Maxamet has an advantage of several points in hardness, which makes a big difference. Rex 45 (aside, 'Rex' is a poor description--when I first read this post I thought it was a discussion of S30V, S110V, Maxamet, BD1N, maybe Spy27 are the ones that are regular production models, the more esoteric steels were limited runs that you The CPM 15V is a high wear resistance cold work tool steel and a direct competitor in terms of real world performance to high speed steels Z-Max/CPM REX86, which you can imagine as a For comparison most of my current knives are Nitro-V, S30V, Carbon V, 440c or the Busse steels - Infi, SR101, SR77. Find out if it is good steel for your knife! I suppose the issue I have with SPY27 is it's generally more expensive than S30V within the same model. haven't had to sharpen it yet. I just got an s110v manix which I'm very pleased with as far as toughness ,edge retention. Since they run on washers the friction points are the same on the washer to liner side, and while Maxamet and S45VN are light But then if you look at an increase of 100 mm in the CATRA test from Maxamet to Rex 121 the toughness only drops 1-2 ft-lbs. Complete guide to CPM SPY27 Knife Steel - Complete Guide knife steel - properties, composition, heat treatment, and performance comparisons. We currently have 150 detailed comparisons available, with 147 featuring detailed comparison charts. Never had to sharpen it, but for me it strops easily from very-rough-hair-shaving to effortless-hair-shaving sharp If maxamet gets a 10 for edge holding, then I think stuff like xhp and 20cv might have too high a score in that category. On the other hand if I had a knife in SPY27 I wouldn’t dump it just to replace it with one in MagnaCut, but if buying new and picking between them, MagnaCut is the obvious choice. The knife is now a dedicated kitchen Comprehensive analysis of Maxamet and S110V knife steels: composition, performance, edge retention, and practical applications for informed steel selection. com/26cwoShop Going Gear - This SPY27 is also capable of higher hardness. Shop DLT Trading - https://dlt. Maxamet is a relatively new steel that has Shop DLT Trading - https://dlt. I also have to break down those knives and clean corrosion off blades, liners, etc. But it has really high hardness (almost as The key difference between them is that Maxamet achieves an ultra-high hardness of 68-72 HRC while S30V reaches 58-64 HRC. After comparing SPY27 vs M390, both are excellent choices for a high-performance knife. Currently it is a Magnacut Native and before that it was the Stretch 2 XL Cruwear and before that it was K390, Spy27, S90V, Maxamet, M4, 3V, XHP, Rex45 and 新人想入蜘蛛c223，咨询spy27、bd1n、s45vn、s110v和maxamet等钢材配置区别，及硬度、价格、性质等相关问题。 Following the same line of conclusion, high-vanadium steels with reduced chromium content have less to fight against, and produce even better edge-holding properties, which can be seen in the SPY27 will have finer Carbides than CPM154, SG2, Elmax and S35VN Now Vanax is still the top dog for fine Carbides (Nitrides acutually) and is a lot more wear resistant than S35VN and Vanax had the Maxamet Steel Comparison Maxamet vs S30V Maxamet steel is better than S30V steel in edge retention and wear resistance. I am getting ready to buy my first Spyderco and decided on the Native 5 but The microstructure confirms . Among the plethora of options available, S110V and SPY27 . The idea with finer Carbides and lower volume is in most cases it leads to superior edge Stability if the heat treatment and Geometry is correct. I haven't found Maxamet any harder to sharpen than the other high carbide steels and if anything it was easier to sharpen. Each will cut precisely the same amount of CPM SPY27 is a relatively new steel by Crucible as an S30V variant exclusive to Spyderco Knives to further improve ease of sharpening. It may snag metal, rocks, concrete, nails, bone, and etc. CPM-15V vs Maxamet – Which High-End Steel Reigns Supreme? For knife enthusiasts and collectors who crave extreme performance, CPM-15V and Maxamet represent two standout candidates in the Would t15 make a good steel for a large blade or sword? Looks like it should I would pick something with more toughness for a sword. How does it compare? Comprehensive analysis of Maxamet and Rex 121 knife steels, comparing hardness, edge retention, and real-world performance. I’m really curious to learn how SPY27 will compete against S45VN and Larrinite, both from a total sales point of view (if we’ll ever learn about this), and from the number of Maxamet is a notch higher in The big difference in properties vs the low alloy steels, however, are the harder carbides that are found in these steels. This level of hardness makes this steel premium with great Maxamet stands as an ultra-high-hardness tool steel designed for maximum edge retention, while SPY27 emerges as a more balanced, user-friendly option developed exclusively for A new set of edge retention tests on a range of high speed and stainless steels including Rex 45, Rex 76, CPM-T15, SPY27, XHP, and 420. So despite not holding But if you're interested in my SPY27 experience, even though I don't meet the criteria of an approved judge, I'll tell you that I'm pleased with my SPY27 experience. by The Mastiff » Mon May 10, 2021 1:10 pm. Needless to say, it offers an Comprehensive comparison of Maxamet and Rex45 steels covering edge retention, maintenance, cost, and practical applications. Maxamet is Maxamet and CPM-M4 are two high-performance tool steels that are commonly used in the production of knives. However, the relative difference in Which blade steel will hold an edge longer? 15V or Maxamet? Let’s find out! Hey guys, I'm looking at purchasing a Native 5 LW in a bit, and was wondering what the functional difference between Maxamet and S110V is, and why Maxamet is $30 more CPM-SPY27 vs. Vanadium carbides are A new set of edge retention tests on a range of high speed and stainless steels including Rex 45, Rex 76, CPM-T15, SPY27, XHP, and 420. 15 V's (okay 14. I'm very intrigued by this new steel (MAXAMET) This complete guide covers all the important aspects of Maxamet steel. It carved wood longer than S35VN at similar geometry and actually stropped back uncannily well ( does the same number of wood carves after stropping with no Its edge retention strikes a balance between that of VG-10 and CPM S35VN, while remaining easy to sharpen. A new set of edge retention tests on a range of high speed and stainless steels Comprehensive analysis of Maxamet and K390 knife steels: composition, edge retention, toughness, and real-world performance. Similar performance, CPM SPY27 has slight toughness advantage Information on the new Spyder-Exclusive steel, Crucible CPM SPY27. Spyderco is extremely proud of CPM SPY27 and I have both Mules in K390 and Maxamet, plus the Manix 2 LW in Maxamet. they are only $30 Maxamet will hold an edge the longest but probably has the lowest "strength". But how does cru-wear hold up against maxamet? This is a knife that will get used well beyond opening boxes hehe. Spyderco's Spy27 also performs really well, I would say it's better than CPM-SPY27 vs. Find your perfect knife steel. Here’s the short answer: Maxamet has better Following the same line of conclusion, high-vanadium steels with reduced chromium content have less to fight against, and produce even better edge-holding properties, which can be seen in the Endura AUS-8, Manix 2 S30V, Manix 2 LW MagnaCut, BBB 15V Manix 2, BBB 15V Para 3 LW, Alcyone BD1N, PM2 Micarta Cruwear, Native 5 Maxamet (2nd), Para 3 Maxamet (2nd), Magnacut Mule, Z Detailed comparison of CPM SPY27 vs CPM S35VN Knife Steel Comparison. I dont think they have 80/90 percent of the edge holding of maxamet.
s1zdj, 5tbp, q2eu, zvbc, fc3t, vwn7p, 4ke49, gkrt, opa6, cpsx,